September's ten most-supported eligible picks went 4–6

Across 4,266 identity-eligible selections, the ten most-supported picks were all NFL spreads. Tarp Sports led the sample-adjusted podcast board in the wider September record.

Picks settled September 1–30, including events played earlier

Coverage matters: all 17 supported sports were evaluated. Incomplete exact identities and source links are excluded from pick-support ranking; the broader scoreboard keeps their settled records.

September at a glance

11,326 decisions, 48.5% wins. The full record was 5,489-5,837-124 across 285 canonical podcast profiles and 1,928 distinct source episodes. Pushes remain in the record and leave the rate denominator. Two losing cross-sport parlays are counted once each, without assigning their legs to one sport.
Football supplied 73.7% of decisions. NFL and college football contributed 8,347; NFL settled at 47.7% and college football at 50.1%. Other sports remain in the full scoreboard.
Tarp Sports led the sample-adjusted podcast board. Its 39-19-3 record includes 58 decisions. 4th & 32 and OddsShopper complete the top three under the same sample-adjusted ranking.

These are descriptive tracked records. Prices differ, selections are correlated, and win rate does not establish profit or a future betting edge.

Most-supported exact picks and outcomes

The ten most-supported picks among 4,266 identity-eligible exact selections finished 4 wins and 6 losses. All ten happened to be NFL spreads. Support determines ordering before the outcome is inspected.

All 17 catalog sports were evaluated, including eligible props, team totals, partial-game markets, soccer conditions, UFC markets and complete parlays. Of 12,662 source mentions, 3,757 could not be grouped safely and were excluded. This ranks the eligible subset, not every stored mention.

Bars show distinct canonical podcast support, scaled to 37 profiles. One podcast gets one vote per exact event, market, period, participant, side, line, stat and complete composite legs. Repeat mentions add receipts, not votes. The ten have 277 show-selection records, 96 distinct profiles and 188 distinct episodes; those are different units from ten outcomes.

Exact-pick coverage and exclusions

From 12,662 source mentions, 8,378 distinct show-selection votes were eligible, 3,757 were excluded and 527 repeated mentions were removed. They formed 4,266 exact groups. All returned groups had their canonical support and episode counts checked. No conflicting outcome or score group remained; each displayed top-ten outcome was independently recomputed from its exact line and final score.

Podcast standouts

The ranking gives less weight to high win rates from small samples. Each show needs a winning record and at least 10 decisions. Tarp Sports ranks ahead of OddsShopper despite a lower raw win rate because its sample is larger.

1.Tarp Sports

39-19-3W-L-P

67.2% wins · 58 decisions

11 source episodes · 3 sports

2.4th & 32

27-14W-L

65.9% wins · 41 decisions

5 source episodes · 3 sports

3.OddsShopper

18-8W-L

69.2% wins · 26 decisions

5 source episodes · 2 sports

All three remain small samples, especially OddsShopper's 26 decisions. This historical ordering does not establish skill, consistent returns or a forecast.

Participation leaders: a separate measure

Sports Gambling Podcast Network
1,081 decisions · 506-575-12 W-L-P · 141 source episodes
Football Picks
678 decisions · 307-371-6 W-L-P · 84 source episodes
The Baseball Betting Show with Greg Peterson
478 decisions · 251-227-12 W-L-P · 31 source episodes

Participation orders by tracked decisions, independently of performance. Sports Gambling Podcast Network supplied the largest sample at 1,081 decisions.

Sports and markets

These breakdowns retain the complete verified September record, including rows excluded from exact-pick grouping. They are sorted by decision count.

Bars show decision volume. The separate win-rate column shows raw historical wins divided by decisions for every nonempty row. Small samples are less stable. Prices and market types differ; rates do not measure returns.

By sport

14 of 17 checked sports had settlements. Bars scale to NFL's 4,468 decisions. Two cross-sport parlay decisions sit outside these sport bars; the sport partitions sum to 11,324.

NFL
184 podcast profiles
2131-2337-43 W-L-P
Decision volume 4,468
Historical win rate
47.7%
NCAA football
119 podcast profiles
1943-1936-38 W-L-P
Decision volume 3,879
Historical win rate
50.1%
MLB
36 podcast profiles
934-972-27 W-L-P
Decision volume 1,906
Historical win rate
49.0%
UFC
21 podcast profiles
200-198-13 W-L-P
Decision volume 398
Historical win rate
50.3%
WNBA
9 podcast profiles
86-123 W-L
Decision volume 209
Historical win rate
41.1%
EPL
19 podcast profiles
57-107-2 W-L-P
Decision volume 164
Historical win rate
34.8%
CFL
10 podcast profiles
74-69 W-L
Decision volume 143
Historical win rate
51.7%
MLS
6 podcast profiles
19-42 W-L
Decision volume 61
Historical win rate
31.1%
NHL
7 podcast profiles
23-20 W-L
Decision volume 43
Historical win rate
53.5%
Serie A
8 podcast profiles
11-6-1 W-L-P
Decision volume 17
Historical win rate
64.7%
Small sample
Golf
2 podcast profiles
1-12 W-L
Decision volume 13
Historical win rate
7.7%
Small sample
Bundesliga
3 podcast profiles
7-5 W-L
Decision volume 12
Historical win rate
58.3%
Small sample
La Liga
5 podcast profiles
3-7 W-L
Decision volume 10
Historical win rate
30.0%
Small sample
Ligue 1
1 podcast profiles
0-1 W-L
Decision volume 1
Historical win rate
0.0%
Small sample

By stored market

Every decision belongs to one stored market category; these sum to 11,326, including the two cross-sport parlay parents. Game totals differ from team totals and player props. Bars scale to the 5,194 spread decisions.

Spreads
219 podcast profiles
2612-2582-77 W-L-P
Decision volume 5,194
Historical win rate
50.3%
Moneylines
227 podcast profiles
1244-1347-17 W-L-P
Decision volume 2,591
Historical win rate
48.0%
Game totals
169 podcast profiles
983-919-23 W-L-P
Decision volume 1,902
Historical win rate
51.7%
Player props
82 podcast profiles
428-521-4 W-L-P
Decision volume 949
Historical win rate
45.1%
Parlays
78 podcast profiles
69-301 W-L
Decision volume 370
Historical win rate
18.6%
Team totals
46 podcast profiles
103-91 W-L
Decision volume 194
Historical win rate
53.1%
Other markets
23 podcast profiles
50-76-3 W-L-P
Decision volume 126
Historical win rate
39.7%

“Other markets” is a stored classification covering 97 UFC decisions, 24 EPL decisions, 1 Serie A decision and 4 MLS decisions, plus 3 UFC pushes. Of its 129 settled records, 123 have an exact parsed type: 82 method-of-victory, 8 goes-distance, 5 any-finish, 14 moneyline, 10 both-teams-to-score and 4 win-to-nil records. Six remain unresolved, so this is a partial breakdown by type. These are records including pushes, rather than decision counts.

Methodology and source limits

Four picks were assigned to Serie A after checking their ESPN event IDs. Their recorded results are unchanged.

Only settled source-episode-backed picks appear. Canonical public Ledger ownership and performance deduplication match Betcast's public profile records. Membership is settlement time, September 1–30 Central; pending picks are excluded. Wins plus losses are decisions; pushes leave the win-rate denominator.

Podcast recognition adjusts for sample size using the established 95% Wilson method (z=1.96): high win rates from smaller samples receive less weight. The ranking requires a winning record and at least 10 decisions; ties use decisions, wins and stable profile identity. This comparison score is not an observed win rate or a prediction. Participation uses decision count. Exact-pick support orders by distinct canonical podcasts with stable identity ties.

Episodes can discuss several wagers, and profiles can share a network. These are not independent opinions or bets. Different lines and periods remain distinct selections. Source links may open a show page or audio file; no verbatim quotation is implied.

Exact grouping preserves provider, event, sport, market, period, participant, side, exact line, stat and every composite leg. Ambiguous identity excluded 3,494 mentions, unsupported markets 230, missing source links 29 and unknown periods four. After removing 527 repeated show mentions, 8,378 show-selection votes formed 4,266 eligible groups. These vote counts differ from the profile-record deduplication used for the overall scoreboard.

This frozen descriptive snapshot establishes no momentum, future edge or profit claim. Small samples, correlated picks, inconsistent prices and historical coverage limits remain relevant.

Inspect a show before drawing a conclusion

Compare the exact call, line and sample through podcast profiles and episode receipts. Further research can include a decision to pass.

Explore podcast rankings

Get the weekly betting podcast rankings report.

Fresh podcast records, ranking updates, and new reports when the data is ready.

September at a glance

Most-supported exact picks and outcomes

1.Houston Texans -2.5

2.Cincinnati Bengals -3.5

3.Jacksonville Jaguars -2.5

4.Denver Broncos -2.5

5.Lions -6.5

6.New Orleans Saints -3

7.Tampa Bay Buccaneers -8.5

8.Carolina Panthers -2.5

9.Philadelphia Eagles -7

10.New York Jets +3.5

Podcast standouts

1.Tarp Sports

2.4th & 32

3.OddsShopper

Sports and markets

By sport

NFL

NCAA football

MLB

UFC

WNBA

EPL

CFL

MLS

NHL

Serie A

Golf

Bundesliga

La Liga

Ligue 1

By stored market

Spreads

Moneylines

Game totals

Player props

Parlays

Team totals

Other markets

Inspect a show before drawing a conclusion

Get the weekly betting podcast rankings report.